Part II: Field Investigators
Rubric: The Extent of the Potential Lead Problem in Ramford
County
|
Beginning (1) |
Developing (2) |
Accomplished (3) |
Exemplary (4) |
|
|
Guiding Question 1 "Sources of Lead" (Project Manager) |
The response addresses possible sources of lead. |
Prior description and sources specific to Ramford County are addressed and the response is supported with specific references. |
Prior description and three of the four major sources in Ramford County are described. |
Prior description and all four of the major sources in Ramford County are described in detail. |
|
Guiding Questions #2 "Relative Concentrations" (Occurrence Specialist) |
The response addresses concentrations of lead in the environment. |
Prior description and specific human activities related to concentration are cited and referenced. |
Prior description and GIS resources are used in the response. |
Prior description plus correct areas/sources of concentration are cited and linked with sampling data. |
|
Guiding Question #3 "Interaction with the environment" (Occurrence Specialist) |
The response addresses how lead is found in and interacts with the environment. |
Prior description, air, water, and soil are addressed, and the response is supported with specific references. |
Prior description, both ground and surface water are addressed as well as information on solubility. |
Prior description and environmental interactions are given relative importance. |
|
Guiding Question #4 "Environmental conditions" (Fate Specialist) |
The response addresses whether environmental conditions affect lead’s bioavailability. |
Prior description and the response is supported with specific references. |
Prior description and each listed condition is addressed. |
Prior description and the response is accurate. |
|
Guiding Question #5 "Persistence" and #6 "Movement" (Fate Specialist) |
The responses address the persistence of lead and its movement within the environment. |
Prior description and the responses are supported with specific references. |
Prior description and the different types of movement and their relative importance is addressed. |
Prior description and the responses are accurate. |
|
Guiding Question #7 "Concentrations within Ramford County" (Transport Specialist) |
The response addresses where high concentrations of lead are likely to be found. |
Prior description and the response is supported with specific references. |
Prior description and the sites are linked to the activities that produced them. |
Prior description, the response is accurate, and it includes the relative magnitude of the various sources. |
|
Guiding Question #8 "Predicting Concentration" (Transport Specialist) |
The response addresses whether high concentrations of lead can be predicted. |
Prior description and the response is supported with specific references. |
Prior description and the how and why of prediction is addressed. |
Prior description and the response is accurate. |
|
Collaboration "Contribution and Responsibility" |
The participant works within their role while researching and gathering information. |
Prior description and the participant shares relevant information with teammates. |
Prior description and the participant has a high frequency of communication with teammates. |
Prior description and the participant completes all work in a timely fashion. |
|
Collaboration "Working as a team" |
The participant provides and receives feedback during the work on section B. |
Prior description and the participant accepts and uses feedback from teammates. |
Prior description and the participant works to include all team members in the process. |
Prior description and the participant works to mediate problems within the team. |